The Armor of Experience

---

My NoSmalltalk session with Bithindra Biswas

by Albert Schiller

Two Classrooms

In the development of a leader, two distinct classrooms exist. The first is the academic one, a controlled environment for studying the theories and frameworks of business. The second is the operational one, an uncontrolled environment where theory often fails. Bithindra Biswas’s career poses a direct challenge to the value we typically assign to each. He argues that his most critical education occurred not in business school, but in situations of practical responsibility where the curriculum was the problem at hand. His experience forces a re-evaluation of where competence is forged.

23, 40, 500

At 23 years old, Biswas was given command of a steel processing plant's night shift. The role's responsibilities were absolute and tangible. He managed a 40-person team of men twice his age, was responsible for seven large machines, and oversaw the logistics of 500 tons of material per shift. This was his case. It directly tested his ability to manage complex human dynamics and high-stakes operational logistics in real-time. The learning in this environment is not theoretical. It is a direct and often harsh education in execution, accountability, and problem-solving that can only be learned under conditions of unavoidable pressure.

The Trial of Guwahati

His next assignment provided an equally demanding education. He was sent to what he describes as a "troubled area" in Guwahati to establish a new bank branch from scratch. This challenge required a different skill set. In a remote location, working with "completely unknown people," he had to be resourceful, adaptable, and capable of building an entire operation without an existing playbook. While his first major role was about managing a complex, pre-existing system, this was an education in pure creation and navigating uncertainty. It was a trial of his ability to function and invent in a high-friction, unstructured environment.

A real-world Paradigm

These two formative experiences lay the foundation for Biswas’s core philosophy on leadership development. He argues that while a business school can provide valuable "theoretical knowledge," it cannot forge the leadership earned in the crucible of real-world challenges. He views this practical experience as a form of "armor," a resilience and an instinct for what works that cannot be learned from a book. His perspective critiques a system that often elevates the theorist over the practitioner, questioning the real-world value of an education alien to operational experience.

5 Lessons with practical values-

Open Questions

1. Biswas’s career suggests that true competence is forged in crisis. Reflect on your own professional journey: was your most critical, formative learning experience a product of a structured, academic setting or an unstructured, high-stakes "acid spill" moment?

2. His call for experience as a prerequisite for a business degree challenges the entire academic-to-corporate pipeline. In your organization, how is "experience" truly valued compared to academic credentials, and does that valuation accurately reflect a person's ability to solve real, unscripted problems?